The following St. John’s gravestone records were compiled by the Athy Cemeteries Committee and given to From-Ireland, with permission to publish, by Michael Donovan, secretary of the Athy Cemeteries Committee.
| Surname | First Name | Age | Last Residence | Date of Death |
| Allen | Eliza | 6 | Cardington | 18/6/1794 |
| Allen | Robert | 5 | Cardington | 24/5/1796 |
| Armstrong | William | 30 | 22/3/1792 | |
| Bennett | Benjamin | 76 | 1/12/1736 | |
| Bennett | Elizabeth | 70 | 1/10/1736 | |
| Booth | Marth | 49 | 4/8/1898 | |
| Beadshaw | Benjamin | 42 | Athy | 17/11/1801 |
| Beadshaw | Christianna | 56 | Athy | 12/3/1874 |
| Chapman | Anna Emilia | 73 | Kingstown | 27/3/1874 |
| Chapman | Robert | 45 | Castlemitchell | 24/4/1836 |
| Clark | Christian | 64 | 1/7/1701 | |
| Clarke | William | 95 | 12/6/1754 | |
| Clayton | Mabel | 12 | 18/6/1887 | |
| Clayton | William | 60 | 25/03/1900 | |
| Clayton | William Beauchamp | 55 | 25/3/1873 | |
| Clover | Bessie | 33 | 18/5/1872 | |
| Clover | James | 2 | 17/12/1869 | |
| Clover | John | 44 | 20/2/1879 | |
| Clover | Sarah | 1 | 3/10/1871 | |
| Crampton | Elsie | 30 | 21/12/1892 | |
| Crampton | James H | 38 | 30/6/1898 | |
| Crampton | Martha | 75 | 21/9/1894 | |
| Crampton | William | 77 | 7/9/1894 | |
| Cross | Alfred Robert | 6 | 9/6/1852 | |
| Cross | Annie | 72 | 28/07/1917 | |
| Cross | Charles George | 18 months | ||
| Cross | Frederick | 52 | Ardmore | 12/9/1899 |
| Cross | George Robert | 18 months | ||
| Cross | Jane E. | 76 | 24/05/1918 | |
| Cross | Mark | 9/9/1864 | ||
| Cross | Maryanne | 50 | 27/3/1899 | |
| Cross | Maryanne | 21/12/1874 | ||
| Cross | Sarah | 4 | 8/3/1846 | |
| Crawley | Henry | 25 | 8/11/1847 | |
| Dove | William | 33 | Hunderclay, Norfolk | 8/11/1847 |
| Duncan | Alexander | 68 | Fortbarrington | 30/9/1887 |
| Duncan | Bessie | 25/10/1852 | ||
| Duncan | Clemintina | 1/1/1832 | ||
| Duncan | Elizabeth | 88 | 04/12/1907 | |
| Duncan | John | 01/01/1932 | ||
| Duncan | Maria P. | 13/04/1907 | ||
| Faulkner | James | 25 | Chester, England | 8/2/1799 |
| Fitzgerald | Winifred Bruce | 1951 | ||
| Glover | Abigail | 72 | Athy | 11/4/1870 |
| Glover | Eleanor | 72 | 22/01/1905 | |
| Glover | James | 84 | 22/9/1884 | |
| Hamilton | Frederick Robert | 4 | 27/3/1873 | |
| Hamilton | Hugh | 59 | 2/5/1882 | |
| Hamilton | James | 15 | 28/5/1873 | |
| Hamilton | Jane | 66 | 23/9/1895 | |
| Hamilton | William John | 28 | 8/11/1890 | |
| Hannon | Eliza | 4 | ||
| Hannon | Emily | 2 | 29/12/1862 | |
| Hannon | Henry | 1 | 20/4/1856 | |
| Hannon | Henry | 63 | Ballyroe House, Athy | 5/3/1888 |
| Hannon | Henry William | 17/5/1851 | ||
| Hannon | Henry | 82 | 5/2/1888 | |
| Hannon | Henry Edward Percy | 24 | 08/06/1918 | |
| Hannon | Henry P. | 42 | Ardreigh, Athy | 13/07/1904 |
| Hannon | John | 95 | 28/3/1855 | |
| Hannon | Kathleen Thomisina | Ardreigh, Athy | 18/01/1918 | |
| Hannon | Thomas J. | 20 | 01/12/1917 | |
| Hannon | Thomas James | 42 | 15/3/1897 | |
| Hannon | Unknown | 4/3/1852 | ||
| Hannon | Deborah Maria | 59 | 7/8/1895 | |
| Harman | Henry | 30 | 5/3/1728 | |
| Harman | M. George | 57 | 1/1/1720 | |
| Harman | Unknown | 31/3/1728 | ||
| Higginson | Edward | 64 | Athy | 15/9/1888 |
| Higginson | Elizabeth | 48 | 16/5/1843 | |
| Higginson | George Robert | 62 | 20/11/1851 | |
| Higginson | John | 72 | 10/10/1852 | |
| Higginson | Joseph | Goullyduff | ||
| Higginson | Joseph | Offaly | 22/1/1780 | |
| Higginson | Mary | 1/1/1746 | ||
| Higginson | Mary Helen | 46 | 6/4/1896 | |
| Higginson | Thomas | 62 | 9/4/1855 | |
| Higginson | William | 18 | 18/4/1852 | |
| Hipwell | Thomas | 27 | Mountmellick | 20/12/1847 |
| Hipwell | Thomas | 57 | 29/4/1852 | |
| Hobson | Abraham | Ballinan | 18/10/1887 | |
| Hobson | Elinor weldon | 08/07/1963 | ||
| Holland | Catherine | 35 | 9/10/1791 | |
| Homes | Elizabeth | 52 | 12/3/1826 | |
| Lefroy | B.L. | 87 | 1/9/1869 | |
| Lefroy | Frances | 18/4/1874 | ||
| Lefroy | Isabella Sarah Anne | 21/03/1916 | ||
| Lefroy | Mary Jane | 18/11/1914 | ||
| Lefroy | Richard T. | 21/12/1914 | ||
| Lefroy | Thomas Langlois | 27/12/1912 | ||
| Lefroy | Mrs B.L. | 35 | 12/6/1830 | |
| Long | Sarah | 43 | 28/11/1875 | |
| Long | William | 78 | 6/12/1891 | |
| Molloy | Clorinda A. | 06/05/1901 | ||
| Molloy | Frederick | 12/8/1825 | ||
| Molloy | George | 30 | 26/9/1848 | |
| Molloy | Hannah | 13 | 1/12/1839 | |
| Molloy | Hannah Anna | 46 | 15/9/1836 | |
| Molloy | Hannah Anna | 5/9/1824 | ||
| Molloy | Joseph Geale | 36 | 12/9/1852 | |
| Molloy | Robert | 56 | 13/7/1836 | |
| Molloy | Thomas | 24 | 10/1/1834 | |
| Molloy | William | 20/9/1896 | ||
| Molloy | Mary | 68 | 4/6/1800 | |
| Mottley | Robert | 30/4/1789 | ||
| Pender | Arabella | 67 | 2/10/1890 | |
| Pender | Elizabeth | |||
| Pender | Elizabeth Maria | 16 | 2/10/1874 | |
| Pender | John | 63 | 13/9/1846 | |
| Pender | Maria | 12 | 6/1/1838 | |
| Pender | William | 82 | 16/10/1894 | |
| Plewman | Ann | 28 | 16/11/1856 | |
| Plewman | Comfort | 16 | 20/4/1824 | |
| Plewman | E.G. | 51 | 16/04/1903 | |
| Plewman | Eliza A. | 83 | 2/3/1897 | |
| Plewman | Maria | 80 | 23/12/1884 | |
| Plewman | Mary | 83 | 7/11/1860 | |
| Plewman | Thomas | 86 | 12/8/1888 | |
| Plewman | Thomas | 49 | 12/11/1820 | |
| Plewman | William | 67 | 3/1/1866 | |
| Plewman | William James | 29 | 25/11/1862 | |
| Roberts | Anne | 19 | 7/2/1839 | |
| Roberts | John | 78 | 19/11/1886 | |
| Short | Unknown | 85 | 15/6/1858 | |
| Smith | Harriet Mary | 73 | 20/06/1933 | |
| Smith | John | 48 | 12/01/1901 | |
| Smith | John | 30 | 9/1798 | |
| St. John | Henry | 76 | 22/3/1879 | |
| St.John | Richard George | 21 | 29/12/1878 | |
| Telford | Isabella | 1/9/1840 | ||
| Telford | Unknown | 4/10/1851 | ||
| Weldon | A.A. | 54 | 29/06/1917 | |
| Weldon | Anthony Aurthur | 01/01/1951 | ||
| Weldon | Eliner Emma | 23/03/1913 | ||
| Weldon | Sir Anthony Edward | 69 | 10/01/1971 | |
| Weldon | Sir Anthony Brian | 74 | 1979 | |
| Weldon | Terrance Gordon | 61 | 01/01/1970 | |
| White | Alicia Frances | 6/2/1879 | ||
| White | Jonathan | 30 | 20/10/1837 | |
| White | Samuel A. | 59 | 9/1/1892 | |
| White | Thomas Maunsell | 53 | 19/1/1833 | |
| White | Thomas Maunsell | 34 | 26/12/1847 |